3 Pieces of Woodworking Media That Messed Me Up
These two books and one video set Ben Strano on a new course. Maybe you’ll be just as lucky as he was.We’ve been having bimonthly builds along with the fun group of woodworkers on our Discord server. (Jump in—the water is fine!). For May/June, we asked folks first to share three pieces of woodworking media they love and then to build something (anything) to hold some form of media—books, magazines, a thumb drive with PDFs, whatever. As I sat down to share my three favorite pieces of woodworking media, I thought I could use it as an excuse to share them with the greater FWW audience too.
So here are two books and one video that have set my work (or life) on a new course. I doubt they will have the same effect on you, but maybe you’ll be just as lucky as I was.
Make a Chair From a Tree by Jennie Alexander
There’s likely more written about Jennie Alexander’s Make a Chair From a Tree than is in the book itself. I bought this book probably 15 years ago when I had more grit than financial resources. At its core, Alexander’s treatise on making a beautiful ladder-back chair with a minimal amount of tools was mind-blowing.
Solid construction techniques built on a foundation of Alexander’s deep understanding of the materials and processes were a siren song for me. I probably read Make a Chair From a Tree half a dozen times while being a stay-at-home dad with an infant. Eventually I bought the companion DVD from Alexander’s website (also available as a download at Lost Art Press) and watched it over and over in between episodes of Pocoyo with my kid.
I never made that chair, though—a regret.
After coming to work at FWW, Taunton Press paid for me to take a Boggs ladder-back class with David Douyard and Jeff Lefkowitz. It was amazing, but I’ll always feel a calling to make an honest Chair From a Tree.
My copy was one of the early pressings from Taunton, and the prices have gotten pretty high due to the collectors’ market. Thankfully, before Alexander’s death, Lost Art Press started working with her on an updated version—with (I’m sure) copious amounts of help from Larry Barrett and Peter Follansbee.
Ironically, I sold both the book and the DVD to help fund a CNC machine.
The Anarchist’s Toolchest by Christopher Schwarz
I’m sure there is a word for the phenomenon where a life-altering event is tied to a seemingly trivial thing, but reading The Anarchist’s Toolchest is a marker in my life. There is no way of knowing whether the changes and emotions I was going through were driven by reading a woodworking book, or if, more likely, I was going through some stuff and I used this woodworking book as a coping mechanism.
At first glance, The Anarchist’s Toolchest appears to be a book about building a tool chest, but in reality, it’s a book about craftsmanship, ideals, and drawing a line in the sand. Yes, there are a lot of woodworking tips and tricks scattered throughout the build. I’m also sure most woodworkers would finish this book and be able to put the woodworking techniques they learned to immediate use in their shop, but I can’t remember a dang one about building tool chests.
What I do remember is ATC bringing on a seismic shift in how I think about the craft of woodworking and, more importantly, how I want to practice that craft. This shift extended past woodworking and triggered a desire for more authenticity in my life, and if I’m honest, made it harder to palate the fakeness of the industry I was working in—the music business. I’m not blaming Chris for making me hate my surroundings, but he didn’t help.
I still have this book. You can’t have my copy. Lost Art Press is weeks away from releasing a revised edition of The Anarchist’s Toolchest. I can’t guarantee what is in it, but if I know Chris (I do), it’s got all the same mojo that I found so important the first time.
Stew Mac’s Watch a Master Luthier Build a Guitar (from scratch)
Full disclosure: I’ve done writing and design work for Stew Mac as well as podcast mixing work for Michael Bashkin. Please trust me when I tell you that this video would be on my top three list if neither of them ever paid me one silver dime or even knew I existed.
It is a rare thing to be able to watch a masterpiece built from beginning to end. As I understand it, Stew Mac sent a video crew over to Michael Bashkin’s shop for months to document the building of a guitar, worth more than (probably) both of the cars in my household. It’s a very difficult task to document something like that without affecting the outcome of the piece. I should know because that’s what we did with our new video workshop, Cabinet on Stand with Tim Coleman (Ha—promo’d you when you least expected it!).
First off, no, this is not strictly a woodworking video. If you’re the type of woodworker who is narrow-minded enough to snub woodworking insight from a guitar maker, move along. This is also NOT a how-to video; instead, it’s a glimpse into the working process of one of the world’s most respected luthiers at the top of his game.
Yes, most of the tools Michael uses are very familiar to woodworkers, but the processes—oh, the smart processes. This is the work of someone who’s obsessed with processes not only to help him chase perfection but to make a living doing it. Michael’s jigs and clever use of CNCs sent my build path on a whole new trajectory. Since this video came out, I too have been chasing efficiencies with jigs and CNCs, and while some might look at it as a rabbit hole, for me it’s part of what I enjoy doing most in my shop, and only a fool would argue it isn’t worthwhile (still, some will).
I have watched this video at least five times. Even so, while I write this blog, having it open in a tab is very tempting. I LOVE this video, and I think you will too.
Comments
I’ve yet to read Jennie’s book but I’ve only heard the best things about it.
As for Chris’: this book would have saved me so much money, time, and frustration if I had picked it up earlier in my journey. The first book I would recommend to most. Well, second after The Very Hungry Caterpillar.
And I’ve also watched that Stew Mac video several times. Aside from being incredibly relaxing, I glean new information from it with each watch.
If I can add one to the list: a chair making video that both inspires me to build and also to throw all my tools in the ocean as I’ll never get close to this level. But I’ll try.
https://youtu.be/rn2K8t33Wts?si=ZwEeEGa2NqYRIZGU
Terrific list, Ben.
Great book choices Ben. ATC changed me as well. I also want to build the JA chair as well. There is a short list of things I've come up with if I had to do my life over again and couldn't be in the sciences. A luthier is high on the list (along with furniture repair/restoration and carving).
The, "Make a Chair" book is excellent, especially the updated version from Lost Art Press. I have yet to build the chair, but I'm assembling the tool kit. Now just waiting for the next hurricane.
Good to see that a new video workshop is out. I think some of the techniques will help with a table I'm building.
Love your selection, Ben. I think I would have started with Roy Underhill's video of making a grease pot ( and yes, I did make six or seven of them) and then gone to Jennie Alexander's book/video and Chris Schwartz's book. I attempted to make the ladder-back chair. I had to have a large hickory tree taken down in my yard and asked for a lower four-foot section to be left. Never could get that log to split and I tried.
I like Christopher Schwartz. He is an inspiration. I enjoy how thorough his research and publications are. I love his 18th century bench and I built my own. I think he is fundamentally wrong about workbench height. The modern woodworker is a hobbyist and unlikely to be planing boards all day long. The higher bench is better for marking, joinery, and final planing. I needed to add nearly three inches of height to my original bench. Now I love it even more!
Oh and I love my tool cabinet on the wall with all the tools in a nice place. I've revised the inside of the Pekovich tool cabinet 4 times over the last decade as I added more planes and gouges. I love it. Would never want to bend down into a tool chest. That's just me.
Lastly, I think Chris should move on from the stick chair. I know he could care less what I think but it's getting really stale and he has almost no other new content to read or watch. It's a bit sad actually because he could offer so much more. Plus I think the stick chairs are ugly.
A short article that's an enjoyable read: Charles Hayward's "Craftsmen I Have Known" -- funny, sad, and everything in-between.
Tool chests were an accommodation to a crowded workshop where wall space was (is) at a premium (windows, et al). The chest sat in the square footage afforded each workman and that was it. Nobody ever liked bending over and sliding tills back and forth. You were not going to show up at a new place of work with a standing cabinet. Today's usually lone hobbyist/craftsman would be much happier owning said standing cabinet. David Powell's design, and nicer versions of it, come immediately to mind. There are others that have been featured in FW over the years. At Chris Schwarz's height, his back must be a wreck. I wouldn't wish a chest on my *aging* worst enemy. Putting the chest on a stool, can even make matters worse. You are still looking down at the tools instead of looking across at them, now not being able to fully let your arms hang to reach what you need - your back angled at an even more compromising position than before.
And, alas, there is a better and much more detailed book on green chairmaking (though not as hip and edgy as Jennie (John) Alexander's later life turned out to be) -- The Chairmaker's Workshop and other green woodworking books by Drew Langsner. Alexander did teach at Langsner's school.
Mike Dunbar's seminal book published by Taunton, also takes you from log to finished Windsor chair, again in enough detail to get a project completed and sitting firm on the workshop floor.
Both authors (Langsner and Dunbar) impart a fair amount of philosophy and the joy of working green wood with mostly, if not all, hand tools.
Log in or create an account to post a comment.
Sign up Log in